Small, Interesting Stores in NYC for the Perfect Gift
New York City is a haven for shoppers seeking unique and unforgettable retail experiences. From artisan-crafted goods to niche specialty stores, NYC is brimming with destinations that cater to every interest, whether you’re a book lover, design enthusiast, or candy connoisseur. This guide takes you through some of the city’s most distinctive shops, spanning charming neighborhoods like Greenpoint, Williamsburg, and the Lower East Side. Each location promises to offer something extraordinary — be it a cozy bookstore or a carefully curated boutique. Get ready to discover the vibrant retail culture that makes NYC one of the most exciting shopping capitals in the world.
MYPLASTICHEART (GREENPOINT)
myplasticheart is a dream destination for toy collectors and art enthusiasts. Specializing in designer toys and vinyl collectibles, this shop offers a rotating selection of rare finds and exclusive releases from global and local artists. Beyond toys, they also feature art prints, pins, and other creative goods, making it an ideal stop for gift shopping. The knowledgeable staff are always eager to share insights about the latest trends in the designer toy world. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just browsing, myplasticheart is a playful yet sophisticated experience.
YOSEKA STATIONERY (GREENPOINT)
Yoseka Stationery is a haven for lovers of fine paper goods and writing tools. This shop celebrates the art of analog creativity with an extensive selection of Japanese stationery, from fountain pens to washi tape. The welcoming atmosphere invites visitors to linger and explore, with a dedicated testing table to try out different pens and inks. Yoseka is also known for its workshops and events, which foster a sense of community among stationery enthusiasts. It’s a must-visit for anyone looking to elevate their journaling, letter-writing, or art projects.
MOGUTABLE (WILLIAMSBURG)
Mogutable is a minimalist lifestyle boutique specializing in beautifully crafted home goods. Their collection features a blend of Japanese and Scandinavian-inspired ceramics, textiles, and decor that radiate understated elegance. Mogutable’s philosophy revolves around curating timeless pieces that bring joy to everyday living. Shoppers will find everything from hand-thrown pottery to sleek kitchenware, perfect for gifting or upgrading their own spaces. The shop’s thoughtful layout and calming ambiance make browsing here a delightful experience.
BOOKS ARE MAGIC (BROOKLYN HEIGHTS & COBBLE HILL)
Books Are Magic is a literary oasis for all ages. This indie bookstore is beloved for its curated selection of new releases, bestsellers, and staff picks across genres. Their vibrant children’s section and frequent author events make it a community hub for book lovers young and old. The eye-catching murals outside the shop are a magnet for photos, while inside, the warm and inviting atmosphere encourages hours of browsing. Books Are Magic lives up to its name, offering readers a magical escape through the power of stories.
PLAYGROUND ANNEX (BED-STUY)
Playground Annex is redefining the concept of a neighborhood shop with its eclectic mix of contemporary fashion, art, and culture. This boutique showcases clothing and accessories from emerging designers alongside a selection of art books and lifestyle goods. Known for its bold, streetwear-inspired aesthetic, Playground Annex is a go-to spot for trendsetters and creatives alike. The shop’s rotating installations and collaborations with local artists ensure there’s always something fresh to discover. It’s a perfect reflection of Bed-Stuy’s creative energy and style.
BONBON SWEDISH CANDY CO. (LOWER EAST SIDE)
BonBon Swedish Candy Co. delivers a sweet escape with its array of Scandinavian treats. The shop specializes in high-quality, sustainably sourced candy, offering a mix of classic and modern flavors. From chewy gummies to licorice, BonBon’s selection is as colorful as it is delicious. Visitors can fill their own bags with a variety of sweets or pick up pre-made gift boxes for any occasion. The bright, cheerful design of the store adds to its charm, making it a joyful destination for candy lovers of all ages.
SWEET PICKLE BOOKS (LOWER EAST SIDE)
Sweet Pickle Books combines a love of books with a quirky twist – selling jars of pickles alongside its secondhand literature. This shop is a treasure trove for those who enjoy browsing for gently used novels, art books, and rare finds. Their pickle selection is equally curated, featuring creative flavors that pair perfectly with an afternoon of reading. The relaxed, community-focused vibe makes Sweet Pickle Books feel like a neighborhood gem. Whether you’re craving a snack or a good story, this shop has you covered.
CODEX (EAST VILLAGE)
Codex stands out as a meticulously curated bookstore with a focus on art, architecture, and design. This boutique shop is a haven for creatives seeking inspiration from beautifully bound monographs and rare publications. Codex also offers an impressive selection of photography books and zines, catering to niche interests. The minimalist decor allows the books to shine as the true stars of the space. It’s a must-visit for anyone with a passion for visual storytelling and high-concept design.
NICONECO ZAKAYA (EAST VILLAGE)
niconeco zakaya brings the charm of a Japanese general store to NYC. The shop offers an array of stationery, housewares, and artisanal goods, all sourced directly from Japan. Every item in niconeco zakaya reflects the shop’s ethos of quality craftsmanship and thoughtful design. From hand-dyed textiles to elegant notebooks, their selection highlights the beauty of everyday objects. Whether you’re shopping for a unique gift or something special for yourself, this boutique is a delightful discovery.
C’H’C’M (NOHO)
C’H’C’M is a menswear boutique offering a refined take on contemporary fashion. The shop is known for its exclusive collaborations and a tightly curated selection of clothing and accessories from independent designers. Quality and craftsmanship take center stage here, with an emphasis on timeless, versatile pieces. The minimalist store design mirrors the understated elegance of the items it houses. For men looking to elevate their wardrobe with distinctive yet wearable pieces, C’H’C’M is an essential stop.
FORBIDDEN PLANET (UNION SQUARE)
Forbidden Planet is a mecca for comic book and pop culture enthusiasts. This iconic shop carries an expansive collection of comics, graphic novels, and collectibles, catering to casual fans and hardcore geeks alike. Forbidden Planet also stocks a wide range of toys, apparel, and imported goods, making it a one-stop shop for all things nerdy. The knowledgeable staff are passionate about their stock, always ready to help with recommendations or special orders. For anyone who loves comics or sci-fi, this shop is a NYC institution.
GLOBAL TABLE (SOHO)
Global Table is a boutique dedicated to elegant, globally inspired home goods. The store’s curated selection includes ceramics, flatware, and decor from artisans around the world. Every piece is chosen for its beauty and functionality, making it easy to find items that elevate any space. Global Table is a great spot to shop for gifts, especially for those who appreciate thoughtful design. With its sophisticated aesthetic and warm atmosphere, the store invites customers to explore and savor the details of each item.
New York City’s retail landscape is as diverse as the city itself, offering something for every taste and interest. Whether you’re hunting for designer toys, artisanal home goods, or rare books, these shops represent the best of what NYC has to offer. And if you’re planning trips to the West Coast, be sure to check out our shopping guides for San Francisco and Los Angeles. Each city has its own unique retail treasures, but NYC’s unparalleled variety ensures it holds a special place in the hearts of shoppers everywhere.
